Gas or Electric: How to Choose the Right Furnace

The furnace is one of the most important parts of a home. It’s what keeps you comfortable, safe, and healthy. There’s nothing worse than having a faulty furnace that can’t make it through the cold winter months. If you’re in the market for a new furnace and need Fort Collins furnace replacement services, it’s helpful to know what type of furnace is best for your house to choose from. Choosing the right type of furnace can help you save money and ensure you’re using a unit that is energy efficient. Here are a few things to consider when deciding if a gas furnace or an electric furnace is right for your home.

Power Source

One of the main factors to consider is accessibility to natural gas. If your home is connected to a natural gas line, a gas furnace is the most common choice. If your home isn’t connected to natural gas, it can be expensive and time-consuming to pipe in natural gas. Plus, natural gas isn’t available in all areas of the country. If natural gas isn’t available in your area, you’ll likely need to get an electric furnace.


In general, electric furnaces are less expensive to install than gas furnaces. However, the cost to maintain an electric furnace tends to be higher than the cost to maintain a gas furnace because it adds a significant amount to your electric bill. Those costs can be planned for, however, with a few budget adjustments. In addition, electric furnaces tend to be easier and less expensive to repair. Click here for more information on the factors that influence furnace costs.


Gas furnaces tend to heat houses faster than electric furnaces. Gas furnaces are also more energy efficient because they don’t waste as much energy as they heat up. However, electric furnaces are more durable and tend to be quieter to operate. The average lifespan of an electric furnace is 30 years, compared to 20 years for a gas furnace.


Gas furnaces emit a small number of gas particles when they run, which presents some risk. If the furnace isn’t properly maintained, there is a risk for accidental fires, explosions, or carbon monoxide poisoning. To run smoothly and safely, gas furnaces require regular professional maintenance. Although these risks are real, they are also very small, and instances of these things happening are rare. Electric furnaces tend to be safer and have less risk involved because they don’t emit any gas particles.

Which is Best?

Your situation will determine which type of furnace is best for you. Consider your location and the availability of natural gas. If natural gas isn’t available in your home, the decision has essentially been made for you. Gas furnaces tend to be better in areas with freezing temperatures because they heat up faster. Electric furnaces are better for warmer climates that don’t put as much strain on the unit. If you won’t be using your furnace as much, the lower initial cost of an electric furnace makes more sense. Electric furnaces are smaller and can be better for smaller homes that don’t require as much heat. You’ll also want to consider the costs—do you prefer a larger upfront cost and lower utility bills, or is it better to pay less money at installation and have a higher energy bill? The choice is up to you. Click here for a list of gas and electric furnace pros and cons.

A furnace is an important investment for your home. Once you decide between gas or electric, trust a professional to safely install your new furnace to keep your home warm and comfortable. Contact American Air today for your Northern Colorado furnace installation.